About 36,000 young fish went into Hinckley Lake in October, and they will spend this winter growing under the ice. For most of the past three years, the lake held very little.
That restocking was the last step in the lake's rebuild. It also explains why this winter at the reservation is unlike any before it. The lake is open, the boathouse is keeping a winter schedule, and Hinckley Township has a run of holiday weekends coming up. The lake itself is in a waiting period, though, and knowing what it's waiting for makes a cold-weather walk to the water more interesting.
What went into the water in October
During the week before October 15, Cleveland Metroparks and the Ohio Division of Wildlife stocked Hinckley Lake with 6,000 juvenile largemouth bass and 30,000 juvenile bluegill. The Metroparks fishing report put the timeline plainly:
"These fish will take around 3 years to grow to harvestable size but the future of fishing at Hinckley Lake is bright!"
The stocking had to wait for a survey. On June 8, Metroparks and Ohio DNR surveyed the refilled lake, found few fish overall, and set the fall stocking from there. So the bass and bluegill in the lake this winter are a starter population, and the three-year clock started last month.
All of this follows a long closure. Metroparks drained the 87-acre lake in 2023 to rebuild a dam first completed in 1927. Cleveland.com reported that about $12 million went into the project. According to Metroparks' project page, crews raised the northern earthen embankment, rebuilt the 150-foot-wide spillway to modern standards, and dredged out excess silt to bring back recreational depths. The Medina Gazette reported that the old lake could handle a 100-year flood but not the probable maximum flood, and that the embankment went up about four feet on both sides.
The lake refilled in fall 2025. Kayak, canoe, and paddleboard rentals came back at the boathouse for Memorial Day weekend 2026, the first full season of services since 2023. This winter is the first one with the new fish in the water.
Why there are plants standing in the middle of the lake
Anyone who has walked the shoreline since the refill has probably seen stems sticking up out of the water near the center of the lake. They were left there on purpose. While the lake was drained, woody and herbaceous plants were established in its center. Metroparks kept them to give fish cover at different stages of growth while the population rebuilds over the next few years.
The stems above the waterline help birds too. Metroparks says waterfowl and songbirds both use them. The young bass and bluegill stocked in October are the fish that cover was left for, which makes a winter walk with binoculars a good fit for the lake this year. An updated fish stocking plan is posted at the Hinckley Lake Boathouse for anyone who wants the details.
The boathouse keeps a winter schedule
The Hinckley Lake Boathouse & Store at 1 West Dr. sells grab-and-go food, drinks, bait and tackle, apparel, and books. Its posted cold-weather hours are below.
| Dates | Hours |
|---|---|
| Fridays through Mondays, through November 30 | 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. |
| December 4 to 7 | 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. |
| December 11 to 19 | 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. |
| December 20 to 23 | 10:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. |
| December 24 and 25 | Closed |
| December 26 to 28 | 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. |
Metroparks notes that the store may open on extra days without notice and that hours can change. The number is 330-278-2160.
Once snow arrives, the boathouse is also where you can rent snowshoes. Metroparks requires at least a four-inch snow base for snowshoeing and cross-country skiing, and when the trails are open for those activities, the hours are 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Guided cross-country ski instruction across the park system usually runs in January and February, depending on snow. The winter activities page is the place to check when a storm comes through.
Ice on the lake, and the rule that goes with it
Under Metroparks' park rules, ice fishing is permitted only where posted, and sledding, skiing, and ice skating are allowed only in designated areas. On its fishing page, Metroparks says anglers 16 and older need an Ohio fishing license and that fishing hours generally run from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m. Rules can change from season to season, so check the Metroparks pages before you head out. This is general information, and the agency's postings are the final word.
With three years of growing ahead of the young fish, most winter visitors will come for the walk, the birds, and a warm drink from the store.
Two projects on the lake's list
The rebuild cleared the way for two smaller improvements around the water. Both are at the grant-application stage.
The first is an accessible kayak launch near the boathouse, along with a replacement observation deck. It would replace a concrete launch area that cleveland.com described as slippery, unsafe, and inaccessible to some visitors. In July, the Metroparks board authorized an Ohio DNR NatureWorks application for $18,786 toward a $25,024 project.
The second is on the Hinckley Lake Loop Trail. The proposal calls for about 1,850 feet of new natural-surface trail plus 1,000 feet of floating boardwalk to replace an eroding section, designed to meet trail accessibility standards. In March, the board authorized an application for about $150,000 from Ohio DNR's Recreational Trails Program. That would be added to a $50,943 NatureWorks grant Metroparks has already received and $29,457 of its own money, for a total of $230,400.
Both projects would make it easier to reach the water. That matters most once the fish stocked this fall grow large enough to draw anglers back.
Hinckley's calendar, November 21 to December 5
Lake visits on a weekend afternoon pair easily with a few things happening in town over the next few weeks.
- Hinckley Holiday Market, Saturday, November 21. The market at Valleaire Golf Club, 6969 Boston Road, is open to the public from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.
- Raley's Tree Farms lot, opening November 21 and 22. Raley's runs a pre-cut Christmas tree lot on Ridge Road in Hinckley, 1.9 miles north of Route 303 and 0.8 miles south of Boston Road. It opens Saturday and Sunday, November 21 and 22, then picks back up Friday, November 27. Hours are noon to 7 p.m. on weekdays and 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. on weekends. The family-owned lot specializes in large trees and carries Fraser, Canaan, Douglas, Balsam, and Concolor firs, plus White Pine and Blue Spruce.
- Boathouse Fridays through Mondays. The store's November schedule runs through Thanksgiving weekend, ending November 30, and its December hours start December 4.
- Hinckley Holiday Event, Saturday, December 5. The Hinckley Chamber of Commerce hosts its holiday celebration from 6 to 8 p.m. at Hinckley Preparatory Academy, with live performances, music, sweet treats, and special guests. The Chamber is still finalizing details.
The Valleaire market and the opening weekend at Raley's fall on the same Saturday. Both are on the north side of the township near Boston Road, so it's easy to do both on November 21.
A lake heading toward 100
The dam behind Hinckley Lake was finished in 1927, and the rebuild wrapped up just ahead of the lake's 100th birthday next year. If the three-year estimate holds, the bass and bluegill stocked this October should reach harvestable size around 2029.
At The Barbara Wilson Team, we follow changes like this around Hinckley Reservation all year, from the boathouse schedule to the lake's restocking. If you'd like to talk about the township, or what's happening around the lake, our Hinckley community page is a good place to start, and we're always happy to hear from neighbors. Contact Us.